Yesterday, an American journalist who was laid off in December wrote a well-received piece for the blog
10,000 Words, entitled
'Why being an unemployed journalist is the best thing to ever happen to me'. In it, the author looked very much on the bright side of life - and even described his time spent unemployed as 'a special opportunity to hone my craft' through learning multimedia skills.
It was a great column, and we're full of admiration for someone who's written an excellent blog and is able to stay so positive at such a difficult time. But at the same time, it was all too familiar. It's a tale we've read so many times over the past six months that frankly, we're sick to death of it.
Listen up publishers, editors, readers - journalism isn't broke. Journalism is about finding stuff out and telling it to other people, and the demand for that is as strong as ever.
The best thing about journalism isn't blogging, or Twittering, or finding innovative
multimeeja ways to tell a story, or even asking someone difficult questions Paxman-style. It's about finding something out that no one knows, and telling people. Simple as that.
And that is why, while we admire the optimism, all this talk of journalism being saved by internet startups and citizen journalists and journalists 'creating their own forms of journalism' is, basically, a load of rubbish. It's playing at journalism, that's all. If you've been made redundant and want to keep your hand in and have no other options, by all means do so - it's better than nothing. But it's not a viable future for the industry.
Journalism should be about the message, not the medium. At the end of the day, journalism's value isn't in how you're telling people something. They might admire the whizzy graphics or fancy audio for a millisecond, and that's it. What they care about - the only thing they've ever cared about - is what you're actually telling them.
Which is why time spent learning multimedia skills is a distraction, not 'a special opportunity'. Journalists need training, and lots of it, but they can only get that training through practice.
Here's a secret - and one that journalism academics, media commentators and the
NUJ with courses to flog will do everything they can do to avoid telling you. If you want to get good at journalism, you have to practice it. Work as a reporter, with a news editor to boss you around and show you the ropes, and report. Learn how to do a vox pop in the pouring rain. Cover a court case when you've arrived late and all your rivals have the story already. Death knock a grieving family. Analyse a spreadsheet full of Government statistics and get the real story. Build contacts.
If you want to be a specialist, don't learn Dreamweaver or podcasting or how to put together Google map. Be a police reporter or an education reporter or a health reporter, and learn your field. Get to know who does what and who will speak to you, find something out, and write the splash. And frankly, who cares who Twitters it to the waiting world? You've filed your story, and you're on to the next one.
Most journalists are born journalists. Some people have journalism thrust upon them, true. But most grow up knowing that they want to be one, and slowly learning how. So don't get sidetracked.
Here at
FleetStreetBlues, we've had other jobs, lots of them. Some casual, part-time holiday jobs - others full-time, soul-destroying PR roles to pay the bills. We don't scoff at those who have to do other jobs - one bad stock market result, one brown envelope and it could be us. But we know what we'd rather be doing.
If you want to be a media publisher, then good luck to you. But if you want to be a journalist, then forget payment models, multimedia development and how to drive traffic. That's not your job. Your job is to be a damn fine reporter and let the chips fall as they may.
If they - the editors, publishers and readers - can't figure out a way to pay for us, then so be it. They'll miss us.
We're journalists. That's all we are, that's what we do. Stop apologising for it.